Category: Strategies

  • Unsure what your ‘thing’ is? Clue #1: it’s what you take for granted

    The more I coach people, the more I realise how annoyingly humble and dismissive us humans can be about the very things that define us. 

    I’d even go as far as saying that there are things about you – inclinations, experiences, stuff you’re capable of, that are so intrinsic to who you are (and what makes you interesting) that you’re practically blind to them. 

    Let me give you an example

    On a typical coaching call, a client and I will meander the psyche in pursuit of ways around an obstacle, when all of a sudden, apropos of nothing comes: ‘that reminds me of the time I got interrogated by the FBI… ‘Next week I’m launching a satellite’.

    Hang on… What? I ask, taken aback. There’s no way I’ll let a glimmer of gold like this get shovelled aside, when we’re figuring out what really makes someone tick. 

    So I press them: go on… 

    Cue a passionate eulogy, a deluge of enthusiasm about their current obsession or tinkering project. Or a curious tale from their chequered past – a man-hunt, a mysterious benefactor, a lost love in a war-torn city. Then along comes the censor to put truth safely back in its box:

    ‘Anyway, weird, I know… not sure what that’s got to do with anything… not that anyone’s interested.’

    To which I scream (internally), are you kidding? 

    What you take for granted is a clue to your place in the world

    These things that seem quite ordinary, having been part of our lives for so long, are often useful clues about which direction to take our careers in. Anything we hastily dismiss as irrelevant, historic, or too weird for everyday consumption – these are indicators of ourselves in our natural, uninhibited, creative state.

    Wouldn’t you like more of these passions and interests in your life? How about meeting like-minded people who are equally fascinated in your experiences and worldview? What if you could get paid for indulging them?

    I’m no stranger to springing this trap myself. For years I’ve secretly been drawn to railway archaeology – disused stations, trackbeds, tunnels, and industry departed. If ever I cycle over an old bridge with ‘BR’ chalked on it, that’s me lost for hours on a curious reverie into the nostalgic mists of time. And don’t get me started on the metropolitan ghosts of Leeds Tramways. 

    Yet I’d filed all this under ‘miscellaneous/other’, content to stare longingly at old maps of transport networks, imagining lost souls conveying themselves through familiar, abandoned locales. I never sang about it in case I came across as a trainspotter (I don’t own a jotter and couldn’t give a flying scotsman about trains). It all seemed too odd and niche, almost workaday, to be relevant to my coaching.

    That was until my own coach recommended I practice what I preach. I haven’t quite worked out how urban mass transit and abandoned railways integrate with my coaching practice yet, but I’m enjoying the process of picking out the bones, in my curious podcast.

    It seems some of us organise our lives into boxes

    Perhaps it’s just my kind of people; the people I coach, but I see this thought-process a lot:

    This is professional… This is personal…. F*** knows what this is, but that can go right to the back of the cupboard – out of sight out of mind.

    When we treat our lives like this, it’s easy to assume one characteristic is more important, valuable or accessible than another. And generally, the box labelled sensible, professional, commercial takes precedence over all others. It’s the box we think others want to see when our cupboard door is opened.

    Yet it’s the combination of everything in there, in balance, that makes us interesting (and valuable) to others as whole, rounded human beings.

    When you talk down your stories, the world’s poorer for it

    That satellite you’re launching on a home-built rocket – do you know how mind-blowing your tribe will find that?

    That story of mistaken identity by an FBI convinced you were a spy – pull up a chair!

    Believe me, there are people out there who’ll deeply value your insight, even pay you for it.

    I recently stumbled upon a blog, curious to see what an acquaintance had been up to. Within minutes I fell down the rabbit’s hole – they too love tinkering with low-cost Linux computers!

    Indulging my curiosity, I found myself doing what every prospective follower of yours will do; wishing I lived more like them. I was drawn to them.

    Trust and intrigue grew

    To those of us on the outside looking in (humans have another bad habit of thinking everyone else leads more exciting lives than our own), this stuff is deeply compelling. We see your worldly, inventive, adventurous value through your interests, hobbies and stories. They draw us towards you, and make us imagine new ways our paths might cross.  

    Curious nuggets of humanity are what people really hope for when they stalk you online. Sure, they want to check you’re legit, but really they long for something unusual, unique and personable.

    A peek behind the curtain.

    Because fundamentally, humans are drawn to novelty, especially when presented through the lens of those who share our values.

    Your curious hobbies, your stories, your idiosyncrasies are irrepressible

    Here’s another phenomenon.

    When I press my clients about their apparently minor hobbies and irrelevant stories, often an opportunity emerges, some change in fortune, or paid work. It turns out some fellow enthusiast found them on the internet, and invited them to collaborate on a project, or funded an experiment.

    So I press yet further – my responsibility as a coach. Don’t you think there’s something interesting going on here? 

    ‘Maybe’, comes the reply, ‘but it was just an accident. I doubt there’s enough of this kind of thing out there.’

    Really?, I ask, do we know that for certain? What would it look like to test that theory?

    Think about it like this: perhaps the real challenge is scaling up what you already do?

    If things are already happening after a handful of sporadic blog posts or tweets, imagine what might happen if you regularly updated a Youtube channel with stuff like this. Or wrote a book about it?

    ‘Oh I’d love to do that,’ comes my clients’ reply. ‘In fact, I did, well I wrote half a book anyway…I make videos about this all the time with my kids…’

    By this point I’m usually gripping the table with white knuckles, trying to retain a semblance of professionalism. 

    ‘Maybe I could take this somewhere?’ comes the realisation.

    Do you think?!?!

    Your curious hobbies, stories and other idiosyncrasies are irrepressible

    Whether you like it or not, it seems our inclinations and experiences always find a way to express themselves. Maybe it’s leaked onto a blog somewhere. Or you allude to it in your bio on your favourite social network. 

    Take a look now. What clues have snuck into your online footprints? Or if they haven’t, what do you avoid mentioning professionally that you’d rather be doing personally?

    Which boxes, full of intrigue and passion, can you delve into at the back of your mental cupboard today, and show to the world, unashamed of your enthralling geekiness?

    Because your tribe is out there, waiting to hear all about it.

  • Here’s an artful way to handle criticism

    Here’s an artful way to handle criticism

    MJ was many things, but not a Shaman. Photo credit: celebrityabc

    Client: “OK, in the headline, change it to ‘add a new strength to your team’”

    Me: “Should we talk about this? I’m not sure that makes sense.”

    Client: “It is new though, and we add strength”

    Me: “But if I visit the gym I get stronger or gain strength, I don’t go to ‘add a new strength’.”

    Client: “It’s based on ‘add a new string to your bow’.”

    Me: “But without the string or bow of the original idiom, it loses meaning.”

    Client*: “Chris you are a supreme creative writing genius, and I’m definitely wrong here, but please just write it that way.”

    When I was a copywriter, I romanticised my role as a quest. A freelancer of integrity – truth, honesty and clarity my allies, on a lifelong crusade to defeat needless jargon and flummery.

    At least that’s what I told myself. 

    When it came down to it, in the midst of an exchange like this, I spoke from a place of fragility. Language pedantry like that above was my defence. 

    Because if you’ve ever been embroiled in a spat like this, you’ll know there’s more at stake than mere diction.

    Criticism feels like attack, by proxy

    This copy, or whatever beautiful thing you’ve invested so much time and effort in, at some point during the creative process, melded with your very being. So to have it criticised, to sully perfection with unsolicited amends, is to question your very esteem.

    As a coach, I’ve heard similar accounts in all walks of life – graphic designers, illustrators, programmers – in fact anyone who absorbs themselves in the things they produce. I’ve even heard of people entangling their self-esteem with formulas in an Excel Spreadsheet. 

    In instances like the one I recount above, some people fail to hear feedback as legitimate, justifiable (however misguided) requests. Polite feedback translates to “this isn’t good enough”, or worse, “you’re a fraud after all, I knew it all along, now everyone will know.”

    Before you know it, it’s not your work that comes out of the exchange sullied and bruised, it’s you and your pride. It’s your very being that’s violated, your right to exist as a flawed human being.

    Not exactly a helpful frame of mind to adopt when there’s urgent pressure to get something finished to an even higher standard. But a common one, nonetheless.

    Maybe you’re a shaman, so try acting like one

    In copywriting circles, writers talk with gusto about voice – developing the brand voice, and how messaging comes across in tone of voice. And I propose that this offers one possible lifeline, an alternative way to handle criticism when it inevitably arrives.

    A copywriter’s responsibility is to nurture tone of voice for your client or employer, right? Or (if it already exists) adopt it, when you write content on their behalf. Same for working to any brand guidelines or style constraints.

    That would make any copy a manifestation of tone of voice, and by implication, the brand or organisation that owns it (and where it stems from). 

    When you think of it like this, it begs the question: is it really the place of copywriters to feel possessive over said copy? Who really owns this voice? 

    Because chances are, it isn’t you.

    Do you follow me? No? OK, let’s look at this another way. 

    How about seeing yourself as a custodian or facilitator? A conduit for someone or something else to speak through. Think like a Shaman, channelling a spirit. You drink the sacred broth, trip out, then vomit up messages from another plane. The spirit lived through you for a brief, fleeting period. 

    But, more importantly, it didn’t become you, nor you become it.

    Your work is art, making it an entity in itself

    This isn’t a particularly novel framework for dissociating self (pride and ego) from what that self produces. Those of you lucky enough to do art foundation or study art at college, may remember this subtle separation.

    Here’s where we start getting a little metaphysical. You might find it helps to read the next few paragraphs in the voice of art-lovie Brian Sewell…

    Art can be an entity in its own right (especially commissioned art). And the artist is a mere conduit for bringing it into existence. Once the thing assumes form (like a whitepaper, a blog post or whatever your specialty) it’s already independent of its creator. 

    When words hit the page, pencil hits paper, your creation is already its own thing. You could even argue ideas are equally distinct – not owned or defining of their creator.

    That’s the pretentious section done.

    Try looking at the things you write or make like that from now on. It offers an instant, handy, alternative mental model for perceiving criticism (especially the negative sort). Because feedback is now about the art, not the artist.

    A subtle distinction, I know. Intellectual, philosophical Nuanced, even – not a concept synonymous in this age of binary culture wars and identity politics. 

    Take the oeuvre of Michael Jackson, for example. When it emerged he was a horrendous sexual predator, media outlets were quick to ban his songs and deny airplay, for fear of association. Which is a bit simplistic and draconian, with the benefit of more hindsight and less manufactured outrage. 

    Bad is a belter of an album. It’s quite easy to enjoy ‘Dirty Diana’ without condoning monstrously creepy pop paedos (probably less so with ‘Just Good Friends’).

    Take your pick of other favourite artists. Dickens was a bit of a love rat, apparently. Yet people glady regard his art as distinct from his fruity philandering.

    These creators may well have been touchy (perhaps sensitive is a better word with MJ) when their art was criticised, but that’s not my point. My point is it’s possible to separate the two, which offers us a handy buffer during confrontations about its perceived quality.

    More nuance and a little distance could be what’s needed here

    What would happen if you began thinking of your creations as entities in their own right? The moment that final full stop appears – that’s that. Here’s an entirely separate thing that’s off out into the world like a fledgling.

    How about thinking of yourself as less parent of what you do or make, and more midwife. Sure, you still get blood and crap all over yourself in the delivery, but once it’s born, you snip the cord and here we have a brand new individual – subject to the slings and arrows of existence on its own terms. 

    What kind of stone-hearted client would criticise a baby, anyway?

    I’ve toyed with this framework in my private projects, seeing them as creations in their own right. And it’s helping soften feedback from that other vocal critic we all know well – ourselves. Probably the harshest sort too.

    Again, art is its own thing is your first line of defence. As above, these creative things deserve an infancy free of censorship. Permitted to live, breathe and grow first – arguably the most gaping pitfall dooming any creative endeavour.

    As for that original exchange with a client: seagulls scrapping over a chip, mate. I coped with countless more during my career as a copywriter, through sheer brute-force and desensitisation. I just wish someone had offered me this nuance, sooner, and a subtle framework to help separate art from the artist, ideally conveyed in a haughty Brian Sewell voice.

    (*= this part of the exchange may have been accentuated somewhat.)